Interesting. If I were to switch to a reefbreeders or an evergrow 36" controllable fixture that would replace my aquatic life 4 bulb T5HO if would cost around $500, and with bulb changes and electricity factored in it would take me 10 years to recoup the cost of the new fixture. Aside from a bit more par, doesn't seem worth the cost. Better fixtures would likely nevr be recouped as they would be obselete by the time I made tha money back. Lol. Now...I know many of us are in the hobby to keep healthy and amazing looking livestock, not to save money. Which is why a lot of people still use MH. Just an interesting tidbit that kind of negates the "cost saving" argument of switching to LEDs.
In short...if you're gonna switch. Don't do it to save money, because by the time you will have saved that money, you'll be looking to buy something new long before that. Do it for better performance
No one has shown me better performance with LED. When enough research is done to show specific spectrum required to grow macro and coral then I would expect performance enhancement. Because LED are mono specific with respect to spectrum, the need to crowd in many different colors arises. Few scientist, even fewer hobbiest, are knowledgable enough about the complexities of different coral spectrum requirement at different phases in the growth of coral. In the greenhouse industry, much money is spent on research and development to light spectrum. Not so in our hobby.
My choice to use LED on some tanks is a combination of heat reduction and a streamlined appearance to the top of the tank. From the perspective of covering all spectrum that may be required by different corals and macro, T5 can not be touched. During the winter time with reduced sunlight in greenhouse grow out tanks, I use MH on moving rails. My objection to MH was large percentage of heat given off. During winter in my outside greenhouse, I need this heat at night to offset heat loss to the night time. The traveling rails eliminate the need for many single point light source fixtures. If you can stand the heat and the extra electrical consumption, MH provide extraordinary lighting effects and growth.
Viva la difference,
Patrick
Agree. The best you can hope for with LEDs is to approximate T-5/MH (which are slightly superior for growth/coloration IMO) at lower energy consumption and heat creation rate.